HomeWorld CricketNine Wickets at Newlands and Six at Mirpur: Who Is Really Writing the Story Behind the Rankings Table?

Nine Wickets at Newlands and Six at Mirpur: Who Is Really Writing the Story Behind the Rankings Table?

মিচেল স্টার্ক কেপ টাউনে নয় উইকেট নিয়ে টেস্ট Bowlingয়ে এক নম্বরে ফিরেছেন, আর সাইমন হার্মার ছয় উইকেট নিয়ে সপ্তম স্থানে উঠেছেন। মার্কো ইয়ানসেন Bowlingয়ে শীর্ষস্থান হারালেও All-rounders তালিকায় এক নম্বরে আছেন। - স্টার্ক: নয় উইকেট, টেস্ট Bowlingয়ে এক নম্বরে ফিরেছেন। - হার্মার: দ্বিতীয় Inningsে ছয় উইকেট, নয় ধাপ উঠে সপ্তম। - ইয়ানসেন: তিন উইকেট, Bowlingয়ে শীর্ষস্থান হারিয়েছেন, তবে All-roundersে এক নম্বরে। - রিকেলটন: ২৫ ধাপ উঠে ২৩-এ; মুল্ডার সাত ধাপ উঠে ১৭-এ। - শাহিন আফ্রিদি: ওয়ানডে Bowlingয়ে পঞ্চম; আইয়ার টি-টোয়েন্টি Battingয়ে সপ্তম। সূত্র: আইসিসি র‍্যাঙ্কিং আপডেট, ২০২৫ | ক্রস-চেকড: cricsultan.com প্রশ্ন: স্টার্ক কি দীর্ঘমেয়াদে টেস্ট Bowlingয়ে এক নম্বর থাকবেন? উত্তর: একটি ম্যাচের নয় উইকেটই র‍্যাঙ্কিং বদলেছে, তাই কয়েকটি সিরিজের ধারাবাহিকতা দেখতে হবে। প্রশ্ন: হার্মারের সপ্তম স্থান কি সব কন্ডিশনে তাঁর সেরা স্পিনার হওয়ার প্রমাণ? উত্তর: না, নিউল্যান্ডসের কন্ডিশন সহায়ক ছিল, বিদেশি মাঠের পারফরম্যান্স দেখতে হবে। প্রশ্ন: ইয়ানসেন কিভাবে Bowlingয়ে পতন আর All-roundersে উত্থান একসাথে পেলেন? উত্তর: তাঁর Batting ও Bowling আলাদাভাবে মূল্যায়ন করা হয়, তাই একই ম্যাচে দুই রকম ফল সম্ভব।

At Newlands in Cape Town, as the late-afternoon light fell and Mitchell Starc bowled the final over of his innings, a name was being written in my notebook—Marco Jansen. Both names sat side by side, because that match had just decided who would stand at the top and who would slip behind. But the story beyond the scorecard, the one the ICC rankings never tell, was different. Starc returned to No. 1 in Test bowling with nine wickets; Jansen lost the top spot—yet the same player who took just three wickets in Cape Town actually extended his lead as the No. 1 Test all-rounder. Two different outcomes from one match. Can a single step measure an entire cricketer? This was the strange, compressed picture of international cricket over the past few days. Across Test, ODI and T20I, the ICC player rankings saw significant movement. The South Africa-Australia Test series, an ODI tri-series, and several T20I series—all folded into one week's ranking update featuring two dozen players. But what this update is really saying, and what it is not, requires separating the formats first. Test bowling rankings and T20I batting rankings cannot be combined to determine a player's overall strength. The ICC itself keeps three separate tables, because the demands of the three formats are different. Hook done; now to the real story. That Test at Newlands was a match where bowlers were the main characters. Starc's nine-wicket match haul—one of the finest performances of his career—directly returned him to the top of the Test bowling rankings. But the question is, how did the ranking system view those nine wickets? The ICC rating method weights recent performance heavily, but career consistency is not ignored. So if one match's performance changes the top spot, it does not mean the bowler is ahead of everyone in the long run. In Starc's case, his career record is strong enough that one big match haul was enough to return him to the top. But this ranking alone cannot prove he is now a much better bowler than Jansen. This is where Simon Harmer's story becomes more intriguing. At Newlands, he took six wickets in Australia's second innings. He jumped nine places to seventh in the Test bowling rankings—a big leap for an off-spinner. But is this leap purely skill, or does condition play a role? Newlands pitches are not usually favourable to spinners, but in this match the ball turned in the second innings. Harmer exploited that opportunity. It is proof of his ability, but not proof that he is the best spinner in all conditions. His overseas performances, his performances against different opposition—these must be watched in the coming series. For South Africa, this ranking update is good news. Jansen remains No. 1 among Test all-rounders and has extended his lead—even though he lost the bowling top spot. This duality is fascinating. A cricketer cannot be labelled simply 'rising' or 'falling'. Jansen scored a half-century in Cape Town, which strengthened his all-rounder ranking. At the same time, he slipped behind Starc in bowling. This means his batting and bowling value must be assessed separately. This is exactly what ranking headlines miss. Among South African batters, Ryan Rickelton rose 25 places to 23rd, Wiaan Mulder rose seven places to 17th, and Australia's Cameron Green and Alex Carey reached equal 19th. These rises are the result of one series' performances. But one series cannot determine a batter's long-term quality—especially when that series is at home. Justin Greaves' ranking jump after West Indies' Test win over Bangladesh in Mirpur is a similar small-sample story. Good performance in one match, a big ranking leap. That is good, but it is not a permanent future position. Now to ODIs and T20Is. Pakistan's Shaheen Afridi is fifth in ODI bowling, Haris Rauf 24th, Fakhar Zaman 37th in batting. These movements reflect tri-series performances. But ODI rankings do not reveal who is an opener, middle-order batter, or finisher. Performance must be assessed by role. In T20Is, Shreyas Iyer is seventh in batting—good news for India, but a ranking position does not reveal how competitive his strike rate is. New Zealand's Mitchell Santner is fifth in bowling, Jacob Duffy 23rd, Afghanistan's Azmat Omarzai third among all-rounders—all signals of recent performance, not long-term evaluation. Here is an intriguing contradiction. The ranking system rewards recent performance, but often a player's ranking rises because other players perform poorly. In other words, your position can improve even without your own improvement. This is why ranking movement cannot be read directly as skill movement—especially when detailed rating points are not published. In this report, the ICC only gave positions, not points. So it is impossible to tell how close or far the top spot is. Another thing to keep in mind. For fast bowlers like Starc and Shaheen Afridi, being at the top of the rankings can create extra pressure. More matches, more overs, less rest—this increases injury risk. This report contains no injury information, but it is a warning for the future. My notebook entry today: rankings are a snapshot of a moment, not a permanent portrait. Starc's nine wickets, Harmer's six, Jansen's all-rounder lead—all are stories of a specific time. Next series, the story will change. The question is, do we read the story through the ranking headline, or do we read the ranking headline through the story? At that Cape Town afternoon, as Starc bowled the last ball, my notebook read next to Mitchell Starc's name: 'Nine wickets, but what about the next match?'

Nine Wickets at Newlands and Six at Mirpur: Who Is Really Writing the Story Behind the Rankings Table?

Nine Wickets at Newlands and Six at Mirpur: Who Is Really Writing the Story Behind the Rankings Table?

Nine Wickets at Newlands and Six at Mirpur: Who Is Really Writing the Story Behind the Rankings Table?